Sonic and the Black Knight Soundtrack

[Ebby]

He doesn't like the OST that i love. I don't like his review, because it is just wrong and incorrect. For example what reason to judge it so low is "Senoue’s scrap-metal"?( I for one LOVE Jun Senoue's work, but i have already said that above.) And after things like that you are bitching about what i said. What a joke!

You don't mind his opinion about the game's OST which he thinks is wrong.. But you are against my opinion about his review which i think is full of fail. I think those were pretty poor reasons to judge the OST so low and that's also my opinion. What's wrong with that?

[eXtaticus]

One unmentioned, yet rather prominent reason for Tales of Knighthood's laughably low score is actually tied to Molten Mine; despite being what is easily the best track on the entire album and a great remix in its own right, it's actually somewhat inferior to the original - in my eyes, if you make a remix of an already excellent masterwork, you have to ensure that the re-creation is better than the original for it to have a purpose. As it stands, it's by no means disappointing in itself, but really doesn't offer anything essentially brilliant to enhance the Black Dawn iteration of the tune.

A real shame, that...

Oh well; just like the rest of the soundtrack, I suppose!

Edited October 14, 2010 by eXtaticus

[Sean]

Alright, because I don't want this to become a second "who hates Kingdom Hearts" topic, I'm going to ask people to please keep discussion strictly on the soundtrack and civil responses to the review. And I know I participated in speaking against ArtFenix as well, so this applies to myself too.

[ArtFenix]

Hm.. I suppose i did sound a bit rough.. Sorry about that. Thanks for clearing that up. Well then..I could say that the review is okay, but i wholeheartedly disagree with it. Sounds better?))

[Snatcher2047]

I'll be the first to admit that even though I highly enjoyed the S&TBK OST, it wasn't one of the absolute best. It had quite a few highlight tracks (Fight The Knight ~Strings~, The Blacksmith, the Excalibur Sonic themes and all the menu themes to name a few), but there really weren't any tracks that were as memorable as say music from SA1/2, Heroes. But it does get some points for all the throwback tracks based on some of the more memorable tracks of Sonic's past.

I'd say it's a solid soundtrack, but by no means a phenomenal one. The vocal CD on the other hand, is easily one of my all-time favorites.

Edited October 15, 2010 by Snatcher2047